New York State's Kosher Inspectors Eliminated

Kosher Inspectors Eliminated - By SUMATHI REDDY -Wall Street Journal

New York state's kosher law-enforcement division has been gutted, sparking concerns in parts of the Jewish community that the cuts raise the risk of fraud in the billion-dollar-plus kosher-food industry.

Under budget cuts instituted by outgoing Gov. David Paterson, the division's eight inspectors and one assistant were laid off starting this year. Two other inspectors retired over the past year and weren't replaced; only the division's director remains. The division is part of the state's Department of Agriculture and Markets.

The elimination of the jobs will save an estimated $1 million a year in salary, benefits and services, such as computers and cars, according to a spokeswoman for the department.

Several lawmakers, Jewish leaders and kosher businesses are lobbying incoming Gov. Andrew Cuomo to restore the cuts. A spokesman for Mr. Cuomo couldn't be reached for comment.

Those who advocate reinstating the inspectors note that the cuts affect not only Jewish consumers, but a growing non-Jewish population of people who eats kosher food, including Seventh Day Adventists, Muslims and individuals with dietary restrictions.

"New York is the largest kosher market in the United States, so we hope that the government can find some place within the budget to, if not maintain the entire department, at least maintain some part of it," said Rabbi Menachem Genack, chief executive officer of the kosher division of the Orthodox Union in Manhattan.

"We understand very well given the budget restrictions… but there is still a need to protect the kosher consumer," he added. "It's not a religious requirement, the issue here is fraud."

State Sen. Carl Kruger, whose district in Brooklyn includes a large Orthodox Jewish population, called the cuts "offensive."

"The need is obvious and the concern is real," he said. "The unscrupulous tactics that some merchants might take dealing with kosher compliance puts the community in a very precarious position in terms of being able to authenticate and feel a comfort level when something is said to be kosher and actually is kosher."

Some say the effective elimination of the division means less since its power was diluted after it lost a law suit challenging the constitutionality of its standard.

The federal suit, filed by a Long Island butcher, claimed the standard discriminated against non-Orthodox purveyors and rabbis. The litigation caused the department in 2004 to rewrite its law. That law was challenged again by the same butcher and remains in litigation.

Jessica Ziehm, a spokeswoman for the department, said under the new law the inspectors effectively stopped doing inspections and instead monitor grocery stores and restaurants to ensure they are complying with an information disclosure act that requires consumers be provided with information on the person or organization certifying food as kosher.

"It basically is to ensure that the information is being disclosed," said Ms. Ziehm. "We don't inspect the meat to see if it's kosher. We ask them to tell us who certified that meat to be kosher."

But inspectors say their work is key to uncovering violations.

Andrew Wolpin, 55 years old, of Brooklyn, is one of the inspectors who was laid off. He said to ensure that a restaurant or store was in compliance he would look at logs, invoices and call kosher certification companies. In one instance, he discovered a Manhattan restaurant that was falsely claiming its meat was kosher. In another, a gift-basket company was claiming its food was certified by Star-K, a kosher certification firm, when it wasn't.

"Now that there's no kosher enforcement it's going to be the Wild West and people will do whatever they feel like," said Mr. Wolpin.

State Sen. Toby Ann Stavisky, whose Queens's district includes a large Jewish population, said with only eight inspectors left, the cost savings wasn't much. "This is not a lot of money," she said. "I think the public has a right to be protected."

Write to Sumathi Reddy at  sumathi.reddy@wsj.com