Sunday, May 18, 2025

Aderei Hatorah event- based on an extremely conservative estimate -Dan-Li'kaf-Ze'chus- דן לכף זכות

Here is a comprehensive analysis of the full scope of bitul Torah (loss of Torah learning time) caused by the Adirei HaTorah event, accounting for all known components: travel, preparation, meetings, logistics, and post-event effects.


 I. CORE EVENT PARTICIPATION

1. Lakewood Yungerleit

  • Attendees: ~8,000–10,000
  • Time Loss per Person:
    • 2 hours travel
    • 3 hours at the event
    • 1 hour prep/socializing
    • 1 hour of lost seder time before or after
    • Total: ~6–7 hours
  • Cumulative Loss:
    → 8,000 × 6 = 48,000
    → 10,000 × 7 = 70,000
     Range: 48,000–70,000 hours

2. Lakewood Bochurim

  • Attendees: ~3,000–5,000
  • Time Loss per Person:
    • Night seder missed
    • Travel & group logistics (~2 hours)
    • Disruption next morning
    • Total: ~6–8 hours
  • Cumulative Loss:
    → 3,000 × 6 = 18,000
    → 5,000 × 8 = 40,000
     Range: 18,000–40,000 hours

3. Out-of-Town Yungerleit & Bochurim

  • Attendees: ~3,000–4,000
  • Time Loss per Person:
    • 6–8 hours travel
    • Missed sedarim before/after
    • Accommodations, fatigue
    • Total: ~8–12 hours
  • Cumulative Loss:
    → 3,000 × 8 = 24,000
    → 4,000 × 12 = 48,000
     Range: 24,000–48,000 hours

4. Roshei Yeshiva / Rabbeim / Chavrei Kollel

  • Attendees: ~500–1,000
  • Time Loss per Person:
    • Shiur prep interruption
    • Organizational roles
    • Travel + attendance
    • Total: ~6–10 hours
  • Cumulative Loss:
    → 500 × 6 = 3,000
    → 1,000 × 10 = 10,000
     Range: 3,000–10,000 hours

5. Baale’batim (Working Men Who Learn)

  • Attendees: ~10,000
  • Time Loss per Person:
    • Night chavrusa / shiur
    • Disruption to morning seder
    • Total: ~1–2 hours
  • Cumulative Loss:
    → 10,000 × 1 = 10,000
    → 10,000 × 2 = 20,000
     Range: 10,000–20,000 hours

 II. INTERNAL BMG LOGISTICS & PREPARATIONS

6. Roshei Chabura Meeting

  • Attendees: ~250
  • Time Loss per Person: ~3.5 hours
    • Central meeting (~1.5 hrs)
    • Follow-up calls/emails (~2 hrs)
  • Cumulative Loss:
    → 250 × 3.5 = 875 hours

7. General Yungerleit BMG-Wide Meeting

  • Attendees: ~6,000–7,000
  • Time Loss per Person: ~2.5 hours
    • Attendance at general meeting (~1 hr)
    • Pre- and post-discussion with chaveirim (~1.5 hrs)
  • Cumulative Loss:
    → 6,000 × 2.5 = 15,000
    → 7,000 × 2.5 = 17,500
     Range: 15,000–17,500 hours

8. Ticket Purchasing and Coordination

  • Families Participating: ~7,000
  • Time Loss per Household: ~1 hour
    • Buying tickets, choosing seats, arranging for kids, carpools
  • Cumulative Loss:
    → 7,000 × 1 = 7,000 hours

 III. INDIRECT AND FOLLOW-UP LOSSES

9. Post-Event Fatigue and Late Start Next Day

  • Applies to many yungerleit and bochurim who return late
  • Estimated yungerleit affected: ~5,000
  • Time Loss: ~1 hour (missed 1st seder or late arrival)
  • Cumulative: 5,000 × 1 = 5,000 hours

 IV. TOTAL ESTIMATED BITUL TORAH

Category

Minimum

Maximum

Lakewood Yungerleit

48,000

70,000

Lakewood Bochurim

18,000

40,000

Out-of-Town Lomdei Torah

24,000

48,000

Roshei Yeshiva / Rabbeim

3,000

10,000

Baalebatim

10,000

20,000

Roshei Chabura Prep

875

875

General BMG Meeting

15,000

17,500

Ticket Coordination

7,000

7,000

Post-Event Lag

5,000

5,000

TOTAL HOURS

130,875

218,375


Summary

The Adirei HaTorah event, while a major display of kavod haTorah, directly results in an estimated:

 130,000 – 218,000 hours of bitul Torah

This figure includes:

  • Actual event attendance
  • Travel
  • Internal coordination within BMG
  • Meetings and ticket logistics
  • Post-event disruptions

Additional Considerations:

  • Wives/Mothers: Lose shiurim, seder hours, household stability, especially if husband is away for long.

  • Post-event lag: The day after has reduced productivity in many kollelim and yeshivos.

  • Prep time for organizers: A select group may lose days or even weeks preparing.

 


7 comments:

Anonymous said...

It's all worth it for those individuals that they live and breath KOVOD, without which למה לי חיים

Cigar Chomper said...

Hey, don't mess with Louie's 'baby'!

Anonymous said...

Large businesses have large expenses. Bituloi hee kiyumo. Add a line for the time it takes yudel to calculate

Alter Mirrer said...

In the late 80s there was an assifa to propose different endeavors to be machzik Torah. R' Shmuel Berenbaum got up & said he is confused as to what the purpose is of the different proposals - just learn! And that was the end of his speech! He also would not attend the various Agudah events, especially the ones centered around essen. The Agudah would send him a limo mit chauffeur but he wouldn't leave the side of his Gemara in beis medrash!

Anonymous said...

For those who are inspired (e.g. me) The Chizuk leads to more and better hours.

Anonymous said...

And there was lots of Essen for Reb shmuel. But he refused that too. Now that’s gadlus. At least on metro corner Bloomies.

Anonymous said...

As it was termed so nicely on Fixing Lakewood - Asirei Hatodah
https://fixinglakewood.blogspot.com/2025/02/adirei-hatorah-or-asirei-hatodah.html