Sunday, November 15, 2026

When Therapy Destroys What Torah Built: Alienation, Therapists, and Botei Dinim

  ·

Anyone who reads our community publications, or who has sat with a family in distress, knows that something has gone wrong. Parents and grown children have stopped speaking to one another. Marriages that might have been repaired are ending. In a troubling number of these cases, the break followed a course of therapy.

Over the same months, the Yated has been publishing the teachings of Rav Shlomo Hoffman zt"l. Week after week, those columns have shown how Torah sources, among them the Rambam's Shemoneh Perakim, the Vilna Gaon on Mishlei, and Rav Yisrael Salanter's Ohr Yisrael, explain the kochos hanefesh and guide a person toward repairing them.

The contrast deserves attention. The same community that reads Rav Hoffman with appreciation sends its sons, daughters, and spouses to practitioners trained on very different assumptions. I believe the family crisis and that contradiction are connected. We have accepted secular psychology as a substitute for Torah wisdom, and we have done so without examining what it teaches.

Different premises

The major schools of therapy start from a secular view of the person that places the self at the center. Freud described man as a collection of drives. Adler described him as striving for power to overcome a sense of inferiority. Much of today's popular psychology goes further and treats a person's feelings in the moment as the most reliable guide to how he should live.

These premises have practical consequences. When someone comes to therapy in the middle of a difficult marriage or a family conflict, a therapist trained this way will often reach for "differentiation" or advise the client to cut off "toxic" people. The Torah sees the matter differently. A parent is an anchor in a child's life, and kibud av va'eim is a foundational obligation that does not depend on how the child feels that week. Under the secular model, a parent or relative who stands in the way of the client's emotional relief can be recast as a violator of boundaries.

How clinical terms are misused

No therapist announces that he is rejecting Torah values. The change comes through professional vocabulary that sounds neutral and scientific. Three terms come up again and again.

Enmeshment. In its proper clinical sense, the word describes a real problem: family members whose lives are so entangled that none of them can function independently. Applied carelessly to a vulnerable client, it turns ordinary closeness into a diagnosis. A mother who calls her married daughter every day, or parents who offer advice and financial help when a marriage is under strain, are described as an "enmeshed system" that has to be taken apart. What the family experienced as warmth is now called suffocation.

Boundaries. The Torah expects that honoring parents and keeping shalom bayis will require sacrifice, forgiveness, and patience with friction. In much of contemporary therapy, a boundary is treated as a wall. A parent's opinion that makes an adult child uncomfortable, or unsolicited advice from an in-law, is labeled toxic. The client learns to tolerate no emotional discomfort at all. In practice that means cutting off parents, ignoring siblings, or treating a spouse's reasonable requests as abuse.

Differentiation. Emotional maturity does require a stable sense of self. But the term is often used to mean something else: leaving behind the family's expectations in order to find one's "authentic self." Used that way, it gives selfishness a respectable name. Obligations to aging parents, or the work of holding together a fragile marriage, are set aside because they are said to interfere with self-actualization.

This is how alienation begins. A client is encouraged to "protect his space," and over time that protection hardens into a refusal to deal with a spouse or parent at all. The other person is no longer seen as a flawed human being who is still owed respect. He is seen as an abuser, or as an obstacle to the client's mental health.

The gap in our Botei Dinim

The way our communal institutions rely on professionals makes the problem worse. When a custody fight or a bitter divorce comes before a Bais Din, the dayanim bring expertise in halacha. Most Botei Dinim, however, have never had a means of evaluating psychological reports and expert testimony on their merits.

In the absence of one, they have deferred to licensed professionals, on the assumption that a university degree combined with a frum appearance ensures an approach consistent with Torah. That assumption is unfounded, and the stakes are high. A therapist's report recommending restricted visitation or supervised contact, or endorsing a child's complete estrangement from a parent, carries great weight with the dayanim. If the Bais Din does not examine the method behind the report and measure it against the standards of Chazal, it may put its authority behind an act of cruelty without realizing it.

What the Torah already teaches

We do not need Freud or a licensing board to explain the human soul to us. Gedolei Yisrael in every generation have taught that the nefesh operates according to laws the Torah makes known, and Rav Hoffman spent decades showing how those teachings apply to real people with real difficulties.

Healing does not come from dismantling a family or from teaching a person to discard whoever challenges him. It comes from working on one's middos, from exercising bechirah over one's impulses, and from accepting the obligations we carry toward one another. That is the message of Rav Hoffman's essays, and it is the opposite of what many of our families are hearing in the therapist's office.

What should change

Therapists who serve our community should examine their own practice honestly. The question each one should ask is whether his work aims at reconciliation, resilience, and respect for parents and rabbanim, or whether it repeats what he learned in a secular program and leaves families permanently divided.

Botei Dinim should establish panels of carefully vetted mental health professionals whose commitment to daas Torah is beyond question. These panels should review clinical recommendations before any decision on custody or family contact becomes final.

The rest of us should stop treating a professional degree as proof of sound judgment. We are entitled to ask a therapist what he believes about family, about obligation, and about the place of Torah in his work, and to expect a clear answer.

The Torah has always been our guide to the human soul and to the conduct of a Jewish home. Our families will be better served when mental health care and the resolution of family disputes are once again governed by it.

by Yehuda Shain - kashrusy@aol.com

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Let's not disparage all batei dinim.

There is, however, one particular bais din, if you can even call it a bais din, that deserves to be distinguished from legitimate batei din. It is comprised not of genuine talmidei chachamim and yirei shomayim, but of professional dayanim whose primary qualification seems to be having taken a dayan training course. Some people become therapists, the smarter ones become professional dayanim. They are prust baal habaatim by any other name.

They handle a large number of gittin cases, yet their approach is neither thorough nor methodical. They rush to determine whether a couple is compatible or whether a marriage can be salvaged, relying on young, arrogant, and inexperienced psychologists rather than conducting a genuinely careful and impartial evaluation.

There is a troubling pattern of taking the side of whichever spouse has stronger connections, apparently because their primary concern is protecting the public image of the bais din rather than pursuing justice.

They allegedly deceive couples into signing arbitration agreements under the guise of shalom bayis consultations. Once the agreement is signed, they assume control of the proceedings and, in many cases, seem more interested in pushing the couple toward divorce than making a genuine effort to save the marriage.

And what happens after the divorce, once the 'job is done'? There appears to be little concern for ensuring that the children have a healthy framework in which both parents remain meaningfully involved in their lives. The result is devastating parental alienation, which they reportedly justify by claiming that their experts believe children who have two parents living under separate roofs will grow up confused.

Anonymous said...

(Continued)
They even have a particularly cruel individual on staff who seems to take pleasure in watching fathers plead for the opportunity to see their own children.

They have mastered a very sophisticated game of keeping the big-name rabbonim pacified. When prominent rabbonim become involved in a divorce case, the bais din is careful to accommodate their positions, often resulting in the husband being branded as an abuser and a loser, seemingly without a fair and impartial examination of the facts.

There are fathers who have gone months, and even years, without seeing their children. Every time they approach the bais din for help, they are either ignored or told to try yet another therapist. These referrals can cost tens of thousands of dollars, often with no meaningful results. There are also serious questions about potential financial arrangements and conflicts of interest involving these referrals and the bully dayan. They internally tire out the party they decided is wrong with the process itself. Date change them in public, and they stop at nothing to destroy any prospect of remarriage.

Their secretary plays the role of Mr. Nice Guy, speaking in a soft, reassuring voice and promising that everything will be okay and that he will take care of it. Meanwhile, the dayan himself has a reputation for being a coarse, aggressive bully.

Recently, they have apparently started using other rabbonim to issue the formal bais din paperwork. But once they secure the parties' signatures on an arbitration agreement, they take over the case from there. This raises serious questions about transparency and whether the parties understand who they are actually placing their trust in and granting authority to.

There is also a well-known, soft and smooth-talking, brand-name Rosh Yeshiva, known to be a pathological liar, who works closely with them and guides them in their manipulation tactics. He frequently gets involved in cases, seemingly sometimes for nothing more than the thrill of exercising power over other people.

The dayan primarily responsible for gittin cases has also developed a reputation for deeply inappropriate behavior, including an apparent fascination with gossiping about the most intimate details of couples' personal relationships. This is particularly disturbing for someone entrusted with handling such sensitive and private matters.

Perhaps just as troubling is the support they receive from other clueless and foolish brand-name Roshei Yeshiva, who defend them from the sidelines with familiar excuses 'The town needs them,' 'To make an omelet, you have to break a few eggs,' 'Divorce cases always involve bitter people.'

They use these excuses to dismiss legitimate criticism rather than honestly examine what is happening. They refuse to be open to hearing complaints about this bais din's methods, its practices, its apparent failure to follow accepted halachic norms, and its lack of accountability.

Being a 'necessary institution' does not grant anyone a license to abuse authority, disregard halachic standards, manipulate vulnerable people, or escape accountability. And the willingness of prominent rabbonim to look the other way does not make these problems any less serious. In truth they are not necessary at all.

Anonymous said...

The בית הבד, the crushing press. Crushing families. Crushing yungerlite. The group of three overweight clowns who proverbially sit and crush those going through a divorce situation.

1. The israeli judge known as Mr. Piggy.
2. The shrink.
3. The Rolex wearing CEO.

Don't let yourself get crushed by these bullies. Stay far away.