Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Is beer kosher without certification?

THE MAKING OF BEER- & Its Kosher Considerations


Beer is classified according to its alcohol content, the bitterness level produced by the hops. The principal kinds of beer are as follows:

Lager: Hops fermentation 10-12 days. After fermentation starts, it continues at a slow pace with the beer stored in cellar conditions. When fermentation is completed, the yeast and some additional substances settle out from the beer. Alcohol content would be between 3% & 4%.

Ale: Fermentation time of 6-10 hours whereupon the yeast is skimmed off the surface of the liquor. The yeast is of a different type than that employed in producing the lager beer. No hops are added and the beer is sweet with an alcohol content of 3%.

Porter: A heavy, sweet ale with an alcohol content of 5%, and contains hops.

Stout: Very similar to porter, but with a higher content of hops.

Malt: The beer is sweet and black, is made with a rapid fermentation that leaves a low alcohol content.

The principal constituents of beer are water, alcohol that is generated from the fermentation of the sugar originating in barley malt and an extract of hops that imparts to the beer its particularly bitter taste. The first stage in brewing, which does not necessarily occur in the brewery, is preparation of the barley.

The barley that serves for preparing the malt is usually of a special species that is grown specifically for this purpose. The two types of barley used for this purpose, are the six-rowed barley that grows in the western parts of the USA, Canada, Europe & Australia, and the two-rowed barley that grows in the Far East and in Europe. The malting starts with the soaking of the barley grains in water at 140F-160F; the water is changed several times, till it reaches a moisture content of 45%.

The barley grains germinate in 4-6 days and start sprouting. In the course of germination there appear in the grain enzymes that decompose the starch of the grain into individual molecules. The glucose molecules in the malted grain are now ready for conversion into alcohol and carbon dioxide by means of yeast that is naturally in the air and in the grain. This action of yeast is that which causes grain dough to become chometz =(leavened).

When the malting process is completed the grain is dried in an oven. (Mashing) The drying temperature sets the color of the beer, because high-temperature drying converts a part of the sugar molecules into a dark substance. In addition, the roasting in the oven affects the grain material, adding taste to the beer. In addition concentrated caramel imparts color to the beer, & is produced separately. The sugar molecules are converted into a dark coloring and are added to the standard malt.

The dry grain that is obtained after roasting is rather stable. It can be shipped over long distances and be stored for a year or more. It is therefore possible to have beer that was sown before the previous Passover and can avoid chodosh problems. It depends in how late the current & the previous spring was as far as planting times.

Brewing: The process of brewing beer itself starts actually with the milling of the malt in order to extract the starches and sugars that it contains. The milling is performed in a manner that would minimize damage to the endosperm & the grain's shell. After milling, the flour is crushed, kneaded & cooked in water at different temperatures in the course of which more starch molecules are converted into sugars. Enzymes naturally present in the grain cause this decomposition just as this happens during malting. The cooking causes the sugars and starch parts to dissolve in water. Insoluble parts of the barley grains remain in the water.

Upon termination of cooking the liquid is filtered and the clear part is called WORT.

Fermenting Beer With Yeast: The amount of sugar that is used in fermenting beer is less than that used by making wine. The yeast will therefore remain active after the fermentation. The alcohol content will be between 3-4%.

The beer liquor that is boiled also sterilizes it from bacteria & therefore it is possible to re-use the yeast & it is very often re-used many times over. These yeasts have to be concentrated when reusing, it can be done by centrifuge or by coagulators of gelatin or vegetable coagulators.

The beer industry employees yeast cultures whose coagulating substance is agar agar extracted from algae-a kosher substance, However, it may also contain in minute amounts peptones which are protein derivatives. The peptones may be extracted from plants and from animal proteins.

A part of the carbon dioxide gas that is generated in the course of fermentation is captured in the closed vessel & dissolves in the beer. This will cause foaming and an antifoam agent will be used which needs kosher supervision. There is also a need for additional foam stabilizes needed in the final product. A common stabilizer is propylene glycol alginate, although inherently may be of a kosher origin it may have been produced on equipment that was used for non-kosher esters.

The production of true, clear beer requires the addition of an enzyme. This enzyme may be derived from microorganisms that were grown on a culture bed containing non-kosher nutrients. The yeast within the culture gets its nutrients from the peptones, develops within the vessels that contain the beer liquor. The question what effect that has on the beer as far as kosher is concerned.

A problem frequently encountered in the marketing of beer is the appearance of a haze that is caused by chilling the beer. This problem is combatted by the addition of papain to the beer "chill-proofing". There are therefore added enzymes to decompose the proteins and allow their re-dissolution. The method of extracting the enzyme from the papaya fruit is by using an amino acid "cysteine" which serves as an antioxidant. Cysteine is extracted from animal & human hair.

They also use OYSTERs in making beer.
http://www.foodmanufacturing.com/scripts/ShowPR~RID~17993.asp

Therefore use only with a proper Hashgocha, one that realizes that a proper hashgocha is required for beer.

RE: VODKA- BTW- All French vodkas are aged in wine barrels, there are many more issues with Vodkas so only use with a proper Hashgocha.

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

So does it need a hechsher?

Anonymous said...

How about a similar discourse on wine? The primary concerns re wine are the yeasts that are used in fermentation (Red Star makes ksoher strains of wine yeast as do other companies), the chemicals used to balance the acid in the must and wine stablizers used to prevent re fermentation (a good discussion here would be appreciated), and products used to clarify wine - some derived from shellfish (most kosher wines use a mechanical filtration process to avoid this problem). But real issues in wine making revolve around the use of chemicals. Do these cover the major issues? If so what do you know about the chemicals used in wine production - are they a problem?

State of the Jews

OU certified said...

http://www.cjnews.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=20131&Itemid=86

Seems like the first time the OU publicly admits that WK has been completely brought up to their standard.

AKO said...

For years, Tylenol, Motrin & many other liquid over-the-counter medicines produced by McNeil in Pennsylvania have been made with kosher glycerin. Although the Pennsylvania plant was not certified kosher, this was welcome news for kosher consumers. Glycerin typically comprises 5-20% of the product. In spring 2010, McNeil recalled many of their medicines and ceased production at the Pennsylvania plant.

This week, the American division of McNeil began distributing grape-flavor Liquid Children’s Tylenol produced in Canada. In coming months, the company hopes to expand this distribution to include other items. McNeil informed the cRc that glycerin used in Canada is derived from non-kosher beef or pork.

Accordingly, we recommend consumers consult with their Rabbi if & when it is appropriate to give these medicines to children.

McNeil produces Extra Strength Liquid Tylenol for Adults (Rapid Blast Cherry) which does not contain glycerin.

Many children are able to use chewable tablets which typically do not contain glycerin (although they may contain other ingredients which are less kosher-sensitive).

Novartis recently introduced varieties of liquid Fever Reducer for children under the Triaminic name. It contains the same active ingredient as Tylenol & bear the OU logo.

Those who chose to avoid uncertified liquid medicine have the following option: In cases where one is unsure if the glycerin is kosher or non-kosher, they may consume the liquid medicine after diluting it 6 times its volume of water or another liquid. Please check with your doctor to determine if this will affect the efficacy or safety of the medicine. The explanation why that is Halachically permitted is beyond the scope of this paper.

Anonymous said...

how about vodka? does this also have the same kashrus issues?

Anonymous said...

There is plenty of beer out there with hashgachas

Pesach hotel fresser said...

Seems like you can't escape Rubashkin even in the Dutch West Indies. The company shipping meat down there is a Rubashkin distributor, otherwise known as South Florida Kosher Meats.

http://www.anivillas.com/anguilla/villas/special-requirements/kosher-dietary-programs

Each of Àni Villas can be rented with Kosher Kitchens. Rabbi Moishe Chanowitz of Chabad St. Martin works together with Àni Villas to certify as kosher the kitchens prior to guests arrival. This includes proper cleaning and sterilization of all cooking appliances, surfaces and equipment. A brand new set of tableware, cooking utensils, pots and pans are provided for your stay, as is a barbeque and dedicated toaster and microwave.

The Àni Villas team will source all kosher foods available on island and pre-stock your home with these items. For all other foods we have our guests order everything for their stay from http://www.mykoshermarket.com/ with whom we arrange and coordinate refrigerated air shipment to the villas in Anguilla prior to your arrival. They offer a wide range of groceries and meats as well as a selection of prepared foods. All food and shipping is at cost to the guest. Our concierge will work together with you and mykoshermaket to coordinate you order.

A $2,000 surcharge covers all certification services, shipment coordination and provision of the kitchen and tableware equipment listed above. Guests have the option of keeping all tableware and cooking utensils or it may be donated to a local charity.

Please contact us for more information on this service and the kosherization process. Rabbi Moishe Chanowitz may also be contacted for further information and details at www.jewishsxm.com.

Didan notzach said...

http://www.shmais.com/printnews.cfm?ID=47523&view=yes&page=print

When did Chabad decide that learning Torah switched from kiddush Hashem to "kiddush shem Lubavitch"?

Dor Yeshorim said...

http://www.thejewishweek.com/news/new_york/training_rabbis_promote_screening

The ultra-moderner Haskel Lookstein from the big shul on the Upper East Side who was megayer Donald Trump's a tochter even she continues to be mechalel Shabbos befarhesya and eat treif has decided that people shouldn't get tested for Tay Sachs because shidduchim are difficult enough already. The chuchem also once came up with a lomdus why people should go listen to kol isha at the opera and bedavka not wear a yarmulka there.

Anonymous said...

Dor Yeshorim:
The Dagim Company Stefansky's used to rip off the signs that said everyone should get tested.

Anonymous said...

The Chabad meshuloch is based in Dutch West Indies but the resort is in British West Indies. In any case, the resort does not cater to Yidden exclusively so if they give any leftover meat to the goyishe guests they would have to inform them it was geshochten under the new European Union's anti-shechita law.

When will Nat Lewin and the Yated figure out they have another excuse to scream ante-Semitten are after Rubashkin?

Anonymous said...

The only tayna I have heard on Dor Yeshurim is that they should not have a monopoly and there are cheaper ways of getting tested.

Does any adam godol or posek say not to be tested at all? Let Stefansky go rip down the signs from his mechutan Paskesz for selling Westheim's gelatin.

Anonymous said...

Dor Yeshorim said...
http://www.thejewishweek.com/news/new_york/training_rabbis_promote_screening

The ultra-moderner Haskel Lookstein from the big shul on the Upper East Side who was megayer Donald Trump's a tochter even she continues to be mechalel Shabbos befarhesya and eat treif has decided that people shouldn't get tested for Tay Sachs because shidduchim are difficult enough already. The chuchem also once came up with a lomdus why people should go listen to kol isha at the opera and bedavka not wear a yarmulka there.

Thu Oct 28, 09:13:00 AM 2010

----------------------------
just informing you that regarding dor yesharim , reb moshe feinstein held the same .

Anonymous said...

First I hear R' Moishe was against Tay Sachs testing. Why then did the yeshivos give open access to Dor Yeshorim to test bochurim bain hasedorim?