Wednesday, December 31, 2014

Rav Shmuel Wosner on kashrus issues in general- לא ראינו אינו ראיה

הרה"ג שמואל הלוי וואזנר שליט"א אמר שמה שהרמ"א אומר ביו"ד ס'' ס"ד סעיף ו' ..צריך ראיה מן הבקי [או מומחה] ואי אפשר לבאר היטב בספר וכו'' בזה נכלל כל עניני כשרות. הרב או הבעל מכשיר מקומו בבה"מ, והמומחה בודק כל הענינים והמציאות, ואח"כ שואל להרב ההלכה והדרך איך לסדר  יצור 
עצהי"ט, אבל רק המומחה קובע המציאות.   וכו
The Experts in insects determined the facts re: Orange Juice infestation.
It's  ובגדר מיעוט המצו' ונראה לעינים

The experts in insects were from Lakewood, Brooklyn, Monsey, Eretz Yisroel, etc.
Some of the experts, Feingold, Strasser, Einhorn, Goldstein, Green, Rav Moshe Vaye, R' Shmuel Sternfeld, etc 

לא ראינו אינו ראיה


Anonymous said...

Golden Flow Orange juice was found to be infested (less than Tropicana). Hisachdus was in a dilemma.

They sent a delegation to Brazil to the plant where golden flow gets their orange juice (3 x annually).

They were unable to find the source of the insects in the finished product on the shelves.

That does not change the fact, Golden Flow Orange juice should alse filtered by the consumer.

Anonymous said...

Hisachdus did not send any mimchim in in insects. A Dayan went and a shamas.

Hisachdis doesn't have anyone that "knows" insects, of course they couldn't find anything in Brazil.

Anonymous said...

ALDI is selling a danish cake that has an ou hechsher- there is milk in the ingridients its missing an OU-D

Dee "beste" shguche said...

"They were unable to find the source of the insects"

Yagata velo matzasa al taamin

Anonymous said...

'sachdis says they have no one that iz a mimcha in toloiyim, so they could give hashgochas to bodek, golden flow, gevina, vikuhainah.

They don't even set the big toloiyim running dee hisachdis.

Anonymous said...

The only apikorsis is to be mevazeh talmid chochom, einer fun der gedolei hador, befarhesya which is what was done by Fri Dec 26, 10:10:00 AM