Saturday, August 09, 2025

Reb Moshe Shternbuch Re: Kashrus unreliability of Rabbi Yechiel Babad and Rabbi Heineman


 

20 comments:

Anonymous said...

You mean they had issues with each other......
Its questionable from a halachic angle if "acahr mayseh" stuff is reliable.

Anonymous said...

Someone spoke to Rav Shternbuch recently, he said the letter is a Teshuvah that is still relevant, then he added perhaps even more so now.

Anonymous said...

Achar mayses is a serious Halacha question. Really it’s not a question but for the kavod of Rav shternbuch …

A bee meh Frrresst said...

Every time an adam gadol has a tayna on a hashgocho that these disgruntled readers like Feb 23, 1:09 PM are fressing from, they come with some kind of tzedreiter "lomdus" to cover up for the bad hashgocho.

Not on Atkins Diet said...

Kinneret is selling frozen cauliflower under Badatz Beit Yosef of EY.

Does that hashgocho eliminate the creepy crawly protein?

Anonymous said...

Assumptions are not facts.

Anonymous said...

“SOMEONE” spoke……
Yeh right…..

Anonymous said...

Fressing is not everything. One does not win by fressing except CCRC of course.

Anonymous said...

He doesn't mention Rabbi Babad at all.

And anyone who learned his seforim knows that he is not a bar plugta of Rabbi Heineman.

Anonymous said...

Look in the bottom letter, he says yechiel babad.

Anonymous said...

It says באב"ד

Anonymous said...

Yet Yudel went down to negotiate with Heineman. BORUCH HaShem they tossed him out by not serving him anything. Not even Water. Boy did he take it personally.
He gave him some new ‘Yochis’ labels.

Anonymous said...

Yudel caught the Star-k with "clam" in their tuna cans that said mashgiach temidi, bishul yisroel and it was cooked on Shabbos.

Anonymous said...

על אשר לא קידמו אתכם בלחם ומים , they were banned from klal yisroel

Anonymous said...

banned permanently from klal yisroel, so the Torah says ban Star-k from klal yisroel on a permanent basis.

Anonymous said...

When yudel confronted them regarding Clam in their tuna cans, The Star-k president told yudel in their office that the Star-K does not him into any iof their facilities as you would see all of the "kulohs, bi'di'eveds, Hetei'rim, etc" we do and you'll tell the gas, so we don't allow you in.

Anonymous said...

The Star-K told the Vaad of Detroit that they can't even find any record that they had and paid a mashgiach fir that production made in the Philipines. Cooked on Shabbos, Clam in some of the Tuna cans, Bishul Yisroel and Mashgiach Temidi.

Anonymous said...

Can someone post the letters against Yudel ??? There are plenty of those out there.
lets be fair and square.

Anonymous said...

Great, who will post them?

Anonymous said...

the "letters" against Yudel

You mean like the "signature" from R' Simcha Bunim Londinski that's a Philly ziyuf? When RSBL explained to R' Elya Ber that they pulled that dirty stunt when he was away in EY, R' Elya Ber gave him a brocho that he should be considered azoy choshuv that it shouldn't be the only time that shysters want to forge his signature!