Saturday, November 21, 2026

The Shtar Beirurin/ Arbitration agreement at Botei Dinim

 A shtar beirurin used to be a short document. It recorded a kinyan and bound both sides to accept the psak of the dayanim. Today many batei dinim hand litigants a multi-page legal contract, and most people sign it without reading it. Several provisions deserve a closer look.

Scope. Many forms bind the parties to arbitrate "all disputes, claims and controversies, past, present or future," not just the matter in the hazmanah. Someone who comes in over a single invoice or a property line may find he has given up the right to bring an unrelated dispute years later to any other forum.

Retained jurisdiction. Some agreements let the bais din keep authority over the parties indefinitely to interpret, modify or enforce its psak. I understand the concern behind this, that a losing party may run elsewhere to reopen the case. But under secular arbitration law an arbitrator's authority normally ends once the final award is issued. These clauses leave the same panel in charge of the parties' affairs for years, long after circumstances have changed.

Waivers. Many forms release the dayanim and the institution from all liability and waive the right to challenge the psak. Some also waive transcripts, discovery or a written decision. Not all of this holds up. Under New Jersey's arbitration act (N.J.S.A. 2A:23B-4 and 2A:23B-23) and New York's CPLR 7511, an award can still be vacated for corruption, fraud, partiality, refusal to hear material evidence, or acting beyond the powers the agreement grants. Neither state lets a party give up in advance the right to be represented by a lawyer.

Din or pesharah. Many forms authorize the dayanim to decide by din or by pesharah, as they see fit. A litigant who came for a ruling on the merits may walk out with a compromise he never agreed to, and no court will undo it, because he signed away that choice at the door.

Custody and children. Some forms are broad enough to cover custody and parenting time. New Jersey courts will not simply enforce an arbitration award on these issues. Under Fawzy v. Fawzy, 199 N.J. 456 (2009), and Rule 5:1-5, there must be a record of the evidence and testimony, and findings focused on the best interests of the child. A bais din that keeps no record and gives no reasons risks having its psak set aside, after the family has already been through the whole process.

A record of the hearing. This should not be limited to custody cases. Every hearing should have a record, whether a recording or written notes kept by the bais din, and the litigants themselves should be permitted to record. Many forms forbid both. Without a record, there is no way to show later what was said, what evidence was offered, or whether a party was cut off. A record protects the dayanim as much as the litigants, and an honest proceeding has nothing to fear from one.

Fees. Some agreements leave the fees open, to be set by the bais din, and make both sides liable for them whatever the outcome. A litigant should know before he signs what he will be charged and on what basis.

How it is signed. Too often the shtar is handed over in the hallway minutes before the hearing, with the implied threat of a seruv for anyone who hesitates. A party has every right to see the form in advance and to show it to his own rav or attorney. Where the other side has chosen the bais din, he also has the right of zabla, to have a say in who will judge him.

A shtar beirurin is a private contract, and no one is obligated to sign an overbroad form as written. A litigant can ask that the agreement cover only the specific dispute, that retained jurisdiction be limited to 30 or 60 days for correcting clerical errors, that the fees be spelled out in writing, that the hearing be recorded and that he may record it himself, and that his statutory rights be preserved. That keeps the shtar what it was meant to be: an agreement to accept a fair psak on the matter at hand.


Wednesday, November 18, 2026

When Therapy Destroys What Torah Built: Alienation, Therapists, and Botei Dinim

 When Therapy Destroys What Torah Built: Alienation, Therapists, and Botei Dinim

Anyone who reads our community publications, or who has sat with a family in distress, knows that something has gone wrong. Parents and grown children have stopped speaking to one another. Marriages that might have been repaired are ending. In a troubling number of these cases, the break followed a course of therapy.

Over the same months, the Yated has been publishing the teachings of Rav Shlomo Hoffman zt"l. Week after week, those columns have shown how Torah sources, among them the Rambam's Shemoneh Perakim, the Vilna Gaon on Mishlei, and Rav Yisrael Salanter's Ohr Yisrael, explain the kochos hanefesh and guide a person toward repairing them.

The contrast deserves attention. The same community that reads Rav Hoffman with appreciation sends its sons, daughters, and spouses to practitioners trained on very different assumptions. I believe the family crisis and that contradiction are connected. We have accepted secular psychology as a substitute for Torah wisdom, and we have done so without examining what it teaches.

Different premises

The major schools of therapy start from a secular view of the person that places the self at the center. Freud described man as a collection of drives. Adler described him as striving for power to overcome a sense of inferiority. Much of today's popular psychology goes further and treats a person's feelings in the moment as the most reliable guide to how he should live.

These premises have practical consequences. When someone comes to therapy in the middle of a difficult marriage or a family conflict, a therapist trained this way will often reach for "differentiation" or advise the client to cut off "toxic" people. The Torah sees the matter differently. A parent is an anchor in a child's life, and kibud av va'eim is a foundational obligation that does not depend on how the child feels that week. Under the secular model, a parent or relative who stands in the way of the client's emotional relief can be recast as a violator of boundaries.

How clinical terms are misused

No therapist announces that he is rejecting Torah values. The change comes through professional vocabulary that sounds neutral and scientific. Three terms come up again and again.

Enmeshment. In its proper clinical sense, the word describes a real problem: family members whose lives are so entangled that none of them can function independently. Applied carelessly to a vulnerable client, it turns ordinary closeness into a diagnosis. A mother who calls her married daughter every day, or parents who offer advice and financial help when a marriage is under strain, are described as an "enmeshed system" that has to be taken apart. What the family experienced as warmth is now called suffocation.

Boundaries. The Torah expects that honoring parents and keeping shalom bayis will require sacrifice, forgiveness, and patience with friction. In much of contemporary therapy, a boundary is treated as a wall. A parent's opinion that makes an adult child uncomfortable, or unsolicited advice from an in-law, is labeled toxic. The client learns to tolerate no emotional discomfort at all. In practice that means cutting off parents, ignoring siblings, or treating a spouse's reasonable requests as abuse.

Differentiation. Emotional maturity does require a stable sense of self. But the term is often used to mean something else: leaving behind the family's expectations in order to find one's "authentic self." Used that way, it gives selfishness a respectable name. Obligations to aging parents, or the work of holding together a fragile marriage, are set aside because they are said to interfere with self-actualization.

This is how alienation begins. A client is encouraged to "protect his space," and over time that protection hardens into a refusal to deal with a spouse or parent at all. The other person is no longer seen as a flawed human being who is still owed respect. He is seen as an abuser, or as an obstacle to the client's mental health.

The gap in our Botei Dinim

The way our communal institutions rely on professionals makes the problem worse. When a custody fight or a bitter divorce comes before a Bais Din, the dayanim bring expertise in halacha. Most Botei Dinim, however, have never had a means of evaluating psychological reports and expert testimony on their merits.

In the absence of one, they have deferred to licensed professionals, on the assumption that a university degree combined with a frum appearance ensures an approach consistent with Torah. That assumption is unfounded, and the stakes are high. A therapist's report recommending restricted visitation or supervised contact, or endorsing a child's complete estrangement from a parent, carries great weight with the dayanim. If the Bais Din does not examine the method behind the report and measure it against the standards of Chazal, it may put its authority behind an act of cruelty without realizing it.

What the Torah already teaches

We do not need Freud or a licensing board to explain the human soul to us. Gedolei Yisrael in every generation have taught that the nefesh operates according to laws the Torah makes known, and Rav Hoffman spent decades showing how those teachings apply to real people with real difficulties.

Healing does not come from dismantling a family or from teaching a person to discard whoever challenges him. It comes from working on one's middos, from exercising bechirah over one's impulses, and from accepting the obligations we carry toward one another. That is the message of Rav Hoffman's essays, and it is the opposite of what many of our families are hearing in the therapist's office.

What should change

Therapists who serve our community should examine their own practice honestly. The question each one should ask is whether his work aims at reconciliation, resilience, and respect for parents and rabbanim, or whether it repeats what he learned in a secular program and leaves families permanently divided.

Botei Dinim should establish panels of carefully vetted mental health professionals whose commitment to daas Torah is beyond question. These panels should review clinical recommendations before any decision on custody or family contact becomes final.

The rest of us should stop treating a professional degree as proof of sound judgment. We are entitled to ask a therapist what he believes about family, about obligation, and about the place of Torah in his work, and to expect a clear answer.

The Torah has always been our guide to the human soul and to the conduct of a Jewish home. Our families will be better served when mental health care and the resolution of family disputes are once again governed by it.

by Yehuda Shain - kashrusy@aol.com

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The following is a partial list of recommended shatnez laboratories:

 


Lakewood-Toms River, New Jersey vicinity:

Shatnez Test Center 732-901-8378

Lakewood Shatnez Laboratory 732-364-7056

Shatnez Lab of Manchester 414-334-8706


Monsey-Spring Valley, New York vicinity:

Monsey-Spring Valley Shatnez Laboratory 845-262-8502

Garneville Shatnez Laboratory 848-245-5347

New City Shatnez Laboratory 303-999-8746


Borough Park section of Brooklyn, New York:

Boro Park Shatnez Laboratory 718-435-0992

Rabbi Wachsman's Shatnez Laboratory 929-585-2424


We plan to add shatnez laboratories in other vicinities.

Saturday, November 07, 2026

Lakewood שלום בית-Therapists (terrorists) are not the solution, they are the root of the problem!


Advice on Responding to a Restraining Order


Unfortunately many women are receiving bad advice from therapists, attorneys and Pseudo Rabbonim who know nothing about Halachah. Their only interest is to pander their client and keep them satisfied. They will never advise their client to do the proper thing according to Halacha, when the client will not be happy with this advice. 
               The result has been a large increase in the issuance of RO’s to Yeshiva Leit. The proper response is to go to Bais Din and request that they commence proceedings to render the sender of the RO a מורדת. If the Bais Din sees that there is no justification for the RO and the issuer does not retract they will commence with the proceedings. The details of what Bais Din has to do are described in Even HaEzer Siman 77. 
As more women get declared a מורדת the reputation of the advisors will deteriorate since we can now quantify that they are giving bad advice and it is producing negative consequences to their clients.

A second benefit is that after the proceedings are finalized there are financial advantages such as no KESUBAH (see Siman 77 for more details)

A third benefit is after 12 months you can give a GET on your terms, and remarry according to most Poskim without a HETER MEIOH RABBONUM if she refuses to accept the GET (see Siman 77 for more details).

A fourth benefit is public relations “He left her because she was a מורדת sounds better than “she threw him out”.
I hope and encourage anyone who has received a RO to go forward with this advice and may הקב"ה give you ס"ד to end these issues with Shalom.
TOSHAV MONSEY
toshav@optimum.net
***************************************************************************

                                                                   Lakewood- שלום בית
Therapists terrorists are not the solution, but the root cause of the problem.